Call Us Today! 716-373-1672

Email Us

Experience Clean & Comfortable Lodging for a Reasonable Price

Experience Clean & Comfortable Lodging for a Reasonable Price

A Motel Dedicated to You

The New Lantern Motel is a family-owned and -operated motel in Allegany, New York. Individuals, families, people here for business, and others will find clean and comfortable rooms with a wide array of amenities to enjoy. Our friendly staff’s committed to making your stay excellent.

A Beautiful & Functional Location

For individuals and families, our motel’s located near a Seneca casino and the City of Olean, home to St. Bonaventure University, restaurants, stores, and arts and culture to experience. Also, we’re close to the renowned Allegany State Park, a place of picturesque views and activities for each season.

Stay here if you’ve come to the area for business meetings or seminars. Also, if you’re a trucker, reach out ahead of time and we’ll organize a parking area for your vehicle. Call us today before booking online for better pricing!

Popular Amenities Offered


Flat-Screen TV

Continental Breakfast

Picnic Tables

Picnic Tables

Daily Housekeeping

Our Guest’s Satisfaction Matters Most to Us

“I stayed in The New Lantern Motel for about a week in October of 2012. My room was meticulously cleaned, and the motel staff was friendly and extremely accommodating. The furnishings in my room were rather Spartan; however, they were much better than I expected them to be at this price-point. In my humble opinion, The New Lantern Motel is quite possibly the best motel value in the Olean area, and I would not hesitate to recommend it to anyone who is looking for clean, convenient lodging while visiting this part of New York State.”
Josh P.

“[I] moved my son into his freshman dorm at St. Bonaventure. Needed to stay the night, and booked this motel a few months ago. Ann, who made my reservation and greeted me when I arrived, has been very friendly like I have known her for a while. The room was great, large, bright and clean, [with a] very large closet, and a good size bathroom. The bed was very comfortable. And a very large flat screen TV. I believe they have the best price in town too. I have already booked my weekend for a family weekend in September. I have found my new overnight place for the next four or five years while I visit my son at college.”
Lisa C.

“I found this motel while searching for lodging close to Rock City in Olean, NY. The New Lantern is very cute and very quiet! The room we stayed in had been recently renovated and was beautiful. It had a microwave and small fridge in there at no extra charge. The lady who worked the desk was very pleasant and funny. Want a nice quiet getaway at an inexpensive price down in southern New York State? Go visit The New Lantern.”
Tammy F.

Call Today to Schedule Your Stay at The New Lantern Motel


The New Lantern Motel
4004 Route 417
Allegany, NY 14706